Crumbs: Reviews » Dramas » Spartacus » Season 3 » The Greater Good
Critical reviews of U.S. TV shows
and analysis of what makes them
good, bad, irritating and enlightening.
60
/100
Viewer
65
/100

Spartacus

Spartacus is a drama about a Thracian soldier imprisoned by the Roman Republic around the turn of the 1st century BC. He is sold into slavery and trained to be a gladiator in the city of Capua. STARZ 2010-???

63
/100

Episode 3 - The Greater Good

8 March 2013

Synopsis: Ashur tortures Oenomaus until he discovers that Spartacus and Crixus are chasing Naevia. While freeing some slaves Agron and Nassir learn that Naevia has been sent to the mines. Agron refuses to go and instead leads his followers to Vesuvius. Crixus and Spartacus head to the mines and Mira leads them to Naevia.

The Good: This was more really solid stuff. It didn't quite hit the emotions the way I would like but there were some really good developments here.

Ashur had an excellent episode. His interaction with Oenomaus was really strong as two established characters did battle over a single issue. Although Ashur was thrilled to pass on a beating to his former doctore he couldn't get a word out of him. So Lucretia unleashes the secret about Gannicus and Melitta which serves its purpose really well. Ashur's glee in these moments marks him out as a true villain and naturally Oenomaus was rattled to suddenly discover the truth about the dark days just before his wife died. The slip he then made about Naevia came out naturally and suddenly Glaber's men knew where to go.  

More than mere plot mechanics Ashur remains in a unique place on the show. He has learnt that doing ruthless things will please his Roman masters and improve his position. Yet he is still a slave. Glaber is more than willing to kill him (after his part in Lycenia's death, 109) and certainly to watch him mutilate himself for fun. So yes Ashur is a snake who enjoys stabbing his enemies in the back but at the same time his loyalty to the Romans is only paper thin. That tense situation leaves him with so much story potential going forward.

The revelation that it was he who saved Lucretia's life and helped stitch her wounds made sense.

The problems in the Glaber-Ilithiya marriage were quietly forwarded here. His obsession is with the manoeuvrings for position in the Senate and not with her. He refers to sleeping with her as a "task" and she clearly thinks his lust for her has gone. It's still hard to find much sympathy for these atrocious people but this presentation of their marital problems was effective.

I also enjoyed a couple of intimate moments amongst the freed slaves. Chadara and Nassir would of course have a pre-existing relationship based on their time as house slaves. So it was nice to see them talking like friends and learn that he is gay. I though Nassir's guilty reaction around a conciliatory Crixus was good too (though more on that later). Then we see her having sex with Rhaskos again but able to laugh and giggle with him now that they have spent time together. I thought that was a further subverting of the expected response from people trapped together like this.

The assault on the mines was beautifully constructed (from a production POV). They looked vast and oppressive and the tunnel network gave us a unique setting for another fight between gladiators and legionaries. Mira got to show her guts by taking on the foreman alone and the reunion between Crixus and Naevia was sweet. Her response to more men's hands on her was believable and the ensuing chaotic fight was pretty good.

The Bad: I felt the story could have been tweaked a bit. I think Crixus was implausibly restrained over Agron's deception. If Nassir hadn't been present when the dying Roman slaver told them the truth then Naevia would have died in the mines. The confrontation between Crixus and Agron therefore felt underwhelming. Agron's argument was undermined by a lack of information about the mines. We needed to hear how many soldiers would be guarding it and get a sense of how tough it would be to find her amongst the thousands there.

Then once in the tunnels there was an edge missing from the action. The claustrophobic interior was doubtless difficult to shoot and so it's a bit harsh to critique the sequence. It was far from bad but Crixus' sacrifice wasn't made as clear as it could have been. I didn't have a strong sense of how many men Spartacus was leading and how many got left behind either.

My real issue with both these Crixus-related scenes is that they serve the TV show in obvious ways. Clearly Agron is going to be a major character now and so it felt like the hatred Crixus should have felt for him was dampened to avoid making Agron seem too reprehensible going forward. Then you had Crixus sacrificing his freedom for Naevia which was always going to feel like a bit of a bait and switch. Naturally none of the Roman soldiers kill him either so we are left to wonder if he is going to be taken back to the villa to have more interactions with Lucretia, Ashur and Oenomaus. That may be great but it will inevitably feel repetitious.

I also laughed when Glaber got cheered in the arena for saying that his men were elsewhere. An audience expecting Roman soldiers would have booed him out of the building before he could get a word out about where they had gone. They then cheered him even louder when he says they are off catching Spartacus but surely they would be more likely to shout back "we'll believe it when we see it!"

The Unknown: How did Lucretia know that Naevia had been sent to the mines? Was that the order once she was done servicing the men of note?

Best Moment: Ashur pushing Oenomaus to reveal something he didn't mean to.

The Bottom Line: Despite my criticism of the TV contrivances here I still thought this was mostly good. Spartacus will now head to Vesuvius while (I assume) Oenomaus, Crixus and perhaps Gannicus plot another escape from Capua.

Feedback

Add your comments on this episode below. They may be included in the weekly podcasts.

Post your comment

Comments

  • It's possible. But they had just cheered loudly at the news that the soldiers would be present. And I think it's safe to say that the soldiers would have done some head chopping themselves.

    Posted by The TV Critic, 21/03/2012 11:15am (6 years ago)

  • Is it possible that a procession of Roman soldiers is NOT what the people were looking forward to? This is a gladitorial arena where the audience seem thrilled to see gladiators take each others heads off, so the news that Glabers' soldiers were in fact elsewhere was met with such approval.

    Posted by Mark B, 21/03/2012 11:14am (6 years ago)

  • Yeah nothing much has been done with Seppia yet so it's been repetitive. I was surprised to learn on your podcast that it was only going to be a 10 episode season. As you said, they are going to have to cram a lot in.

    Posted by The TV Critic, 21/03/2012 11:14am (6 years ago)

  • I loved your comments regarding Glaber's performance at the arena. Come to think of it, what an interesting turn of events it would have been for him had he gotten booed out of there instead of receiving such high praise.

    I too share your concern regarding the Crixus/Naevia bait and switch. My guess is that Crixus' capture will serve as the hook to bet us back to the arena. I felt no connection to the gladiators who were fighting at the same time as the events in the mines were taking place. Perhaps bringing Crixus back to the arena is the producer's way to continue the show's connection this element of the show, which had more prominence in previous seasons.

    How do you feel about Seppia? I'm really starting to dislike this character and don't see much use for her. Either her storyline needs to turn around, or they should figure a gruesome way to kill her off.

    Roberto Suarez
    Portland, OR
    JupitersRooster.com

    Posted by Roberto Suarez, 21/03/2012 11:14am (6 years ago)

  • Hello Robin,
    This was once again another fantastic episode of Spartacus. This episode was a lesson in tension, benefitting from the set up episode that was last week. Our knowledge of the new characters and the past history of the old ones began to mingle with this episode. The result was a gradual buildup of tension as each thread of the story, started to come together. With every scene in the episode, it ratcheted up until the final explosion in the mines.
    Old storylines that I thought would be done with reared its ugly head in the most unexpected way as Ashur tortured Oenomaus. Even as Lucretia whispered it to Ashur I couldn’t help gasping as I realized what might come. It was a masterful stroke of storytelling, filling me with confidence that this story is going to be well told.
    Although I already know the end of this story, it still manages to surprise me at every turn.
    Several great scenes in this episode:
    Spartacus trying to console the heart broken Crixus, was as emotional a scene between two men as could be seen on TV.
    I loved the torture scene, especially since the writers didn’t make the characters dumber or destroy their integrity. There was no way Oenomaus was going to give in to Ashur, but the clue was pried out while staying true to their characters.
    The opening shot of the mines really brought home the enlarged scale that this show is now on. While the fight scenes haven’t all been satisfactory, it is obvious that the technical aspects of the show are much better.
    This week also saw the revelation of the new Navia. Still not sure of what to make of her, but I am sure we will get the opportunity to find out. Speaking of new actors in old roles, Liam McIntyre is really growing on me as Spartacus. Even though he’s not Andy, his take on the role is definitely his own, but believable.
    One last thing, I loved how Lucretia looked on in almost glee as she realized the strife between the other Romans. I cannot wait to see what she does with those dynamics.
    I can’t wait to hear your podcast this week, thanks for the forum Robin.
    Kayode from Baltimore

    Posted by Kayode from Baltimore, 21/03/2012 11:13am (6 years ago)

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments