Crumbs: Reviews » Dramas » Shameless » Season 2 » A Bottle of Jean Nate
Critical reviews of U.S. TV shows
and analysis of what makes them
good, bad, irritating and enlightening.


Shameless is a comic drama about the impoverished Gallagher family living in suburban Chicago. Alcoholic-absentee father Frank is nominally patriarch of the family but the real work is done by daughter Fiona. Then Lip, Ian, Debbie, Carl and Liam make up the rest of the family. Showtime 2011 - ???


Episode 7 - A Bottle of Jean Nate

7 March 2012

Credit Showtime

Synopsis: Frank is deeply irritated by having to look after Peg. When she enlists Carl to set up a meth lab in the basement Fiona joins Frank in trying to get rid of her. Jasmine hosts a boat party and invites Steve so Fiona can spend time with him. Kev and Veronica bicker over whether to go look for Ethel or not. Ian and Lip fight to resolve their differences. Karen gets sick of Jody, kicks him out of the house and pulls Lip back in to her life.

The Good: As usual Kev and Veronica had the best story built on simple emotions. He misses his surrogate daughter and she feels guilty for perhaps being partly responsible for Ethel leaving. Their love for one another remains touching and their decision to have a baby of their own is a natural conclusion to the Ethel story.

Jasmine's story has been built well since the end of last season. Amy Smart has given a good performance and always seemed a little more into touching Fiona than a friend should be. If you throw in the loveless marriage and constant attempts to drag Fiona along on her nights out then their kiss made perfect sense. In a way Jasmine is a reflection of what Fiona could be but isn't. Jasmine was also stuck in a home full of kids when she didn't want to be. But instead of knuckling down and being responsible she tried to escape from it and now has nowhere to go. It's been a solid story but it's not clear where it goes now.

The Bad: The Peg story still isn't much fun to watch. Her attempt to restart her meth business was unforgivable and the cancer suggests she will now be hanging around neutering Frank for many episodes to come.

The Karen-Jody story was appalling. After six episodes of professing her love for him she wakes up one day and is suddenly sick of him. That's it. She goes from deeply in love to hatred in one day. If the point of this story was that Karen truly is the psychotic whore her Father claimed she was then I suppose it made sense. But that wasn't the tone I picked up on. Jody was suddenly presented as a bit pathetic in the way he made love and was in love with her. We met his tattooed friends who bluntly illustrated the downside of having children and Jody nodded along uncomprehendingly. He was then mocked for being stupid and sat outside the house singing to her, again in a supposedly annoying way.

That's how I read the tone anyway. Perhaps I'm wrong because what came across to me was quite the opposite. Jody didn't come across as annoying to me, he came across as passionately in love. He didn't seem stupid, he seemed trusting. His serenades spoke of his utter dedication to his wife in the face of irrational rejection. The fact that Karen jumped straight back into bed with Lip cemented her as an utter heel.

I don't know what to think of it all. As I said, if the purpose of this was to kick Jody off the show and reunite Lip and Karen then it was an utter failure. If that turns out to be what happened then it exposes both Karen and the writers in a horribly unflattering light. If I was meant to feel revulsion for Karen then it was still bad television (because of the confused portrayal) but mission accomplished I guess.

I wasn't happy with Kev and Veronica shipping Stan off to the nursing home. Surely she could lose her job over this and Stan's family need to be informed about what's going on. The fact that they didn't discuss the bar is another problem because surely that issue should be concerning Kev. I also thought the joke where Stan tried to leave for his baseball game naked was worse than cheap. The presentation of senility in such implausible fashion for the sake of easy laughter didn't sit right with me. We all laugh at Abe Simpson gags but when you go this far with it it becomes something else.

The Unknown: It was good to see Fiona taking a stand against Steve too. She clearly hates that she loves him and is smart enough to see that he isn't stable enough to be what she needs. He looked pretty douchey throughout the episode (including his choice of clothes), blowing off his new wife and expecting Fiona to ignore his lies. The problem is that television shows don't make a habit of showing us love stories that go nowhere. The "happy ending" right now would be for Steve to go away and for a new man who can support Fiona to appear. Somehow I doubt it will be so simple.

The Lip-Ian argument hinted at some depth to their feelings. When Ian complained that Lip would waste his life by staying with Karen I got a Good Will Hunting vibe. Perhaps it wasn't that Lip had been mistakenly handed the West Point application that bothered Ian. Perhaps it was that Lip would never consider filling it in. Once they fought though Ian went back to seeming pissed off at the misunderstanding and claiming that he lived in his brother's shadow.

However the episode ended with Lip dropping out of school and trying to find a job. What could be going on here is the idea that Lip has turned into Frank. He is throwing away his life on a crazy girl (who Frank likened to Lip's mom) and we should feel afraid for this wasted potential. If that is the direction of the story (particularly considering how unlikable Karen is) then it could be pretty interesting.

Best Moment: Kev had some fun moments while high on cocaine but the best moment was probably him and Veronica trying to catch Ethel 2 in the garden.

The Bottom Line: These last few episodes have been very troubling for Shameless. It's not the bad writing that bothers me as much as the return of all the characters to their season one situations. Lip is back with Karen. Sheila is back in her house. Steve is back trying to win Fiona over. Shameless is really good when it breaks from TV convention and shows us a grittier American family than we are used to. If it becomes a lame procedural comedy like any other then it will be a huge letdown.



Add your comments on this episode below. They may be included in the weekly podcasts.

Post your comment


  • Darci, I agree completely in regards to Amy Smart. When she popped up at the end of the first season I figured her character would be a one and done or a two and done. I've been pleasantly surprised to see her in a guest starring role all throughout, and she certainly brings credibility to the role. I just wonder, after this episode, where she continues to fit. Maybe her arc isn't over just yet?

    Posted by Brando, 20/03/2012 4:44pm (8 years ago)

  • I love how they have developed Fiona this season. She's still a strong young woman trying to hold everyone together, but her vulnerability and struggles make her even more humanized, add depth, etc. She's definitely the best character on the show, despite the amazing performances William H Macy has given as Frank.

    Some other quick notes - Amy Smart sure does crazy well as Jasmine, and I like how this side of her had been hinted at, but somewhat ambiguously before, so you never knew quite what to expect as to just how crazy she was. Also, as always, great use of music, really loved it when they played "In the Dark" by Dev when Fiona, V, and Kev arrive at David's Raging Boat Party.

    Posted by darci, 20/03/2012 4:43pm (8 years ago)

  • Agreed :-(

    Posted by The TV Critic, 20/03/2012 4:43pm (8 years ago)

  • Really was disappointed in this episode.

    I could care less about Steve. His reintroduction has been stupid and I'm not at all rooting for Fiona to be back with him.

    This show just took a giant, huge, massive dump on Jody and basically rendered much of the past 6 episodes obsolete. Every interaction Karen had with Lip in defense of Jody or why she was with Jody now rings massively false. We were given no reason to believe Karen couldn't stand Jody or that she was so completely dissatisfied with him. Last episode I complained that we had no choice but to root for Lip, but this episode just took that theory to the 100th power and made Jody look like a complete fool and made Karen look petty and completely stupid for rushing into the marriage. At least before we were supposed to believe she really liked him.

    And things were just naturally fine between her and Lip after he said he wanted her to get an abortion? Guess they patched that up in between episodes right around the same time Karen decided she couldn't stand Jody.

    Can't Lip go to school and get a job?

    How many times have we seen the "big fight" between two characters that ends in them suddenly back to being fine because they got their angst out and now need a nice cold beer together? The cold war between Lip and Ian was dumb to begin with, but the climax and resolution was even dumber.

    Hopefully the next episode can bounce back...this is the first time I've felt very let down by the show.

    Posted by Brando, 20/03/2012 4:43pm (8 years ago)

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments