Crumbs: Reviews » Dramas » Homeland » Season 1 » Grace
Critical reviews of U.S. TV shows
and analysis of what makes them
good, bad, irritating and enlightening.
62
/100
Viewer
65
/100

Homeland

Showtime

67
/100

Episode 2 - Grace

6 March 2012

This was a good follow up to the excellent pilot.

It started strong with a graphic dream sequence of Brody burying his comrade. And then the doubts begin as to whether he really is a terrorist. He seems so disturbed by his return to reality and haunted day and night by memories of his torture and captivity. Finally though he goes down on his knees to pray to Allah. That was a big moment because I had questioned whether religion would play a part in what turned him.

The key to this episode was the nature of exploitation when it comes to the war on terror. We see Brody's military and CIA bosses pushing him to not only talk to the media but also to come back to work. They argue it will help mould the public's expectations about continuing the war in Afghanistan. They don't mention the obvious: that it will be a boost to their own careers. They put dark pressure on his friend Mike who they know was sleeping with Brody's wife.

The sympathy that this situation generates for Brody is then cunningly mirrored on Carrie's side of thing. Rather than being the champion of justice and truth Carrie is sending her own soldier out into unknown territory. Her asset is a member of the Saudi Prince's harem. The glimpse into the auditioning process for that gig was a surprising and clever way to expand the world this story takes place in. Carrie is told by the same CIA boss to put this girl in danger with no extra protection in place. Carrie goes through with it and the whole sad chain of people exploiting those beneath them for the sake of this war goes on.

I thought it was a strong and sad message. In a way Brody becomes the hero of the piece when he says he won't go back to work for the military. But of course by episodes end he marches out in uniform to meet the media and Carrie thinks that's because he plans on playing the hero in order to get to his eventual target.

Elsewhere we see that Carrie gets her meds from her sister which gives a fig leaf of cover to something that viewers didn't find believable. On the downside though one of the implied pressures on Brody is the financial pressure to provide for his family. I don't buy that for one second. Without any real knowledge I'm still sure that the US military not only provides good pensions for veterans but for a man held for eight years as a prisoner of war I know there would be big compensation money. Not to mention of course that Brody could sell his story for millions of dollars.

Anyway, this was good dark stuff and confirms this show as the best new one to air in the fall so far.

('DiggThis)

Feedback

Add your comments on this episode below. They may be included in the weekly podcasts.

Post your comment

Comments

  • I'm only two episodes in, but already I really enjoy this show. At this point I think either Brody is not a terrorist at all, or that he's stuck in something a little more complicated than being the POW who has turned.

    The only thing that really has tipped the iceberg in this direction was him praying to Allah. That, to me, was the strongest indicator that he will not turn out to be a straight up traitor or terrorist. Obviously the show is and will be more complex than just one simple statement, but in this world of touchy political correctness as what not I'd be very surprised if the writers and network would have the balls enough to have a white American character become a terrorist and have a conversion to Islam be a part of that. It just seems too convenient and too close to the stereotype of what Americans at large have been afraid of and have perceived as evil and/or indicative of terrorists since 9/11.


    That's not to say I'd be upset one way or the other if it were actually the case, I'm just speculating as per the norm for me.

    Posted by Brando, 20/12/2011 9:03pm (6 years ago)

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments