Crumbs: Reviews » Dramas » Game of Thrones » Season 1 » Winter is Coming
Critical reviews of U.S. TV shows
and analysis of what makes them
good, bad, irritating and enlightening.
62
/100
Viewer
71
/100

Game of Thrones

HBO

65
/100
Viewer
65
/100

Episode 1 - Winter is Coming

24 February 2014

Credit HBO

Game of Thrones - 101 - Winter is Coming

Synopsis: The King of Westeros heads north to recruit his old friend Ned Stark to replace his now dead right hand man Jon Arryn. Stark is a man of his oath and prepares himself and his family for this change in their circumstance. Before he leaves though rumours reach him that Arryn was killed by the Lannister family (one of whom is Queen). Across the Narrow Sea Viserys Targaryen prepares to take back the throne he believes was stolen from him. He is trading his sister Daenerys for the army of warlord Khal Drogo.

The Good: The opening scene was fantastic, as it should have been. The effects were movie-quality as a detachment of guards head past the huge northern wall and are soon cut to pieces by terrifying "White Walkers." It told you a lot about the budget behind Game of Thrones as well as the supernatural threat that lies beyond the medieval palace intrigue going on elsewhere.

That intrigue was fairly solid though with Ned Stark (Sean Bean) a reassuring pillar of morality holding everything else up. In an episode which had to cover a lot of ground only a few characters could stand out and he was one of them, at this stage clearly the main character. His resolute morals were demonstrated in the way he executed a deserter, instructed his children on the care of their new pets and instantly knew that he would have to do the King's bidding regardless of his own preferences. That morality not only gives us a valuable guide to his behavior but also helps us relate to what his many children must be going through as they all fight for their own place at the table.

The other man to stand out was Tyrion Lannister, the dwarf brother of the Queen. Now it's easy to stand out at that size and when you spend your afternoon at an orgy. However he also showed off his attitude to life by basically saying that he has learnt to accept his stature as an important part of who he is and not let people's preconceptions drag him down. His wisdom and self esteem contrasted nicely to the final standout character Daenerys Targaryen (she of the flaxen hair) who personified ignorance, innocence and naivety. It was easy to feel sorry for her as her brother sold her off to the most effective murderer he could find and patted her on the head for questioning his decision.

In general the characterization was what it needed to be at this stage. The boobs and expletives made it clear that this is not a kids show and yet old and young characters' stories were told so it should have a broad appeal. The dialogue was mixed but despite all the new names and place names I followed along just fine.

The world of Game of Thrones was fairly easy to get a handle on by episodes end and the most impressive part was the scope. We swept across four quite different landscapes and were able to sample the medieval, the byzantine, the alien and the mythology all in one episode. The show is making it clear that it has ambition and will be detailed and thorough as well as visually interesting.

The Bad: I wouldn't say anything was bad yet...

The Unknown: Though the final scene was an odd one. Young Bran Stark accidentally discovers the Queen having sex with her twin brother. Yikes. But then Jaime tosses Bran off the wall and presumably to his death in order to protect the secret.

I've never seen a show which successfully killed off a small child in its pilot so I'm going to assume that Bran lives and I'm never happy with cliffhangers which seem so unfulfilling. It was also played in a flippant manner which made the ideas of murder, incest and adultery all seem less serious as a result. Of course without seeing what happens next I can't conclude anything but it was not a great closing scene.

There were also a couple of lines from across the Narrow Sea which seemed needlessly heavy handed. First Viserys tells his sister that he would let horses rape her in order to become King. It was way too much from a character who already had shades of being a pantomime villain. Then later we learn that the Dothraki have no word for "thank you." That may be accurate but in a pilot episode it might have pushed the odd viewer to feel the show was being too silly for their tastes.

On the general mystery front of course we want to know who the White Walkers are, what their powers are and to what extent is magic a part of this universe. But as we go on there are bound to be a ton of additional historical questions cropping up. For now I want to know when and why was the giant wall constructed? How is the succession to King decided and how big are the Seven Kingdoms on this planet? And does Targaryen have a legitimate claim to the throne?

Best Moment: The opening scene was terrific and as good as anything you will see in the cinema.

Conclusion: This was a promising debut for Game of Thrones, no doubt. I have not read the books nor do I know anything about them beyond the obvious. I will judge the show entirely as a TV product and would appreciate no spoilers being posted on this page. To be a great pilot the story would have had to focus in a lot more on a few people but I appreciate that this is not what the story demands. Game of Thrones is going to be a multi-season project and the universe needs to be carefully constructed. I'm looking forward to watching more.

P.s. for new viewers (like me), I found this very helpful http://www.tv.com/untitled/story/25617.html?tag=headlines;title;5&tag=topslot;title;

Feedback

Add your comments on this episode below. They may be included in the weekly podcasts.

Post your comment

Comments

  • Good:

    The wall; the white walkers and Direwolves had me hooked. I have to know why the wall exists.


    Most of the acting I thought is pretty solid. For me, character wise the ones that most interested me were: Sean Bean (Ned Stark) and Peter Dinklage (Tyrius Lannister) and Mark Addy (King Robert Baratheon). All these actors very quickly breathed life into their characters engaged others and established framework for the kingdom, humanness.

    The opening credits; sets and costumes are rich, detailed and amazing. A lot is conveyed with very brief looks required.

    Bad:

    There’s a lot being thrown at the watcher. I have not read the books nor will I until
    the show concludes.

    Unknown:

    Will Bran survive?
    Will the queen and her brother be outed eventually for their indiscretions?
    What is causing the savage ruthlessness of the white walkers?
    Which side of the wall are the attacks being made to members of the kingdom?
    What is the magical connection between the House of Stark and Direwolves?
    Specifically what is the connection between the Direwolves and Bran?

    Viewer score: 65 / 100

    Posted by Fluids, 24/02/2014 6:58pm (4 years ago)

  • Hi Tim,

    Your English writing here is excellent. If you hadn't made it clear that it wasn't your first language I wouldn't have noticed!

    Thanks for commenting and your attitude towards spoilers is perfect, thank you.

    You can definitely use anchor the way you did. And I agree that Ned came across as a rock of stability. I agree with everything you said about the pilot and look forward to hearing more.

    Posted by The TV Critic, 18/04/2011 9:07pm (7 years ago)

  • I'm happy to know that you're gonna review this show as well - I followed your "Lost" and "The Walking Dead" reviews, but as it takes me roughly ten years to translate my thoughts on an episode into English, I had to wait for you to review a story that's alreay been out for roughly that time. Yes, this may be an adaptation of the book series, but i still have a head start. ;-) (... and neither the vocabulary nor the brain power to spoil something this complex - so no book spoilers here, I can guarantee that.)

    First of all, the opening sequence is amazing. As John Locke once said: "We're going to need to watch that again." I read somewhere that the sequence will be changed to show whatever cities are relevant to the episode - and for some episodes this should be really helpful. Much like HBO's viewer's guide. In a way, this is the polar opposite of "Lost". Imagine a season 5 episode open with a similar camera flight across the island and eventually through time...

    Anyway, if "Winter is Coming" had one problem to overcome, it's probably the amount of information they had to get across. In some scenes that is very well done, but others had a few lines of let-me-remind-you-of-your-brother-and-father-riding-south, or this-is-Jamie-Lannister. While I feel that the show could have waited with some parts of exposition until later on, the introduction of the main characters seemed pretty effective to me. They may not appear to be very complex at this point, but we're given a basic idea of all of them.

    Most of all I enjoyed the way Ned Stark is established - with him killing the good guy from the prologue. How he does it and why he'd never order an executioner to kill someone he himself sentenced to death, how we see him as a loving father and husband - who is still determined to leave his family behind when duty calls... This may sound odd but he's like this big, difficult-to break and easy-to-understand rock at the center of the main storyline, and I hope that he can somewhat anchor the new audience whenever thing's get a little convoluted. (To anchor someone - can you say that in English? Or does it imply violence?)

    But in the end this will be an ensemble show, and though most of it's characters are really great, I can't say how much of that you can transfer into this other medium within 'only' ten hours and a lot of plot to tell. Going forward, I will try to think of this less as an adaption (because then I wouldn't be exactly commenting on the show itself) and more of it's own thing. Which so far... Looks very promising.

    Posted by Tim, 18/04/2011 7:39pm (7 years ago)

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments