Crumbs: Reviews » Comedies » Community » Season 4 » Alternative History of the German Invasion
Critical reviews of U.S. TV shows
and analysis of what makes them
good, bad, irritating and enlightening.
52
/100
Viewer
72
/100

Community

NBC

68
/100
Viewer
73
/100

Episode 4 - Alternative History of the German Invasion

5 April 2013

Credit NBC

I liked this a lot. This was quite a cleansing experience for me.

I've complained for the last two seasons that Community had badly lost its way. The promise of season one was squandered for the sake of chasing references down rabbit holes and exposing the callous core of our characters and then forgetting that what they did last week had actually happened.

This episode attempted to right all those wrongs in one bold move and unexpectedly succeeded. For a start the plot was built around a class. The show is called Community, as in Community College, as in learning and studying. The way previous classes have been dismissed as mere distractions from the business of being silly has been a constant irritation. Here History class was used to remind the group about their own history as well as setting off a fun war parody which drove the plot forward nicely.

The German puns (that Troy didn't get) and the Dean's puns (which no one but the viewer could follow) gave the dialogue more of the snap and crackle that it used to have too. The German jokes were predictable but served the story and the war analogy was a lot of fun. Like in any classic sit com the Germans were always one step ahead and the conflict reached a really fun climax with the breaking-chair sequence that hit the parody-plausibility line just perfectly. I liked that there was room for Abed to have his own subplot about honouring the bond he'd developed independently with Karl.

The study group cunningly defeated the Germans (mocking Greendale's oversensitive reaction to cultural celebrations) but instead of that being the end of things we got a proper Community-style twist. Years of selfishness in the study room come back to bite them when the rest of campus takes the Germans side and protests their domination of the only nice room Greendale has to offer. This scenario is a meta-commentary on the inevitable fact that our study group are the main characters on the TV show and that using one set is a lot cheaper than finding multiple places for them to hang out.

Dan Harmon always seemed to think that this meta-commentary was more valuable and funnier than it ever was. His indulgence in it destroyed the sense that these were real people actually attending College. The new show runners gloriously used that weakness as a strength by having the group accept their selfishness and do something about it. That was such a strong and happy ending, something so many episodes were crying out for over the years. Repairing other study rooms was the ideal place to stage their "reparations."

If this is the final year of college and of Community then I would loudly applaud more stories like this which push the characters to take genuine positive experiences from their time at Greendale. It seems like that's what's being done with Chang who is being rebooted from zero. I suppose it could all be a giant act on his part but it would be better for everyone if he built up a new personality without the insanity.

('DiggThis)

Feedback

Add your comments on this episode below. They may be included in the weekly podcasts.

Post your comment

Comments

  • I’ve been impressed by the fact that along with trying to keep the essence of what makes Community special from 5 other similar sitcoms, the new showrunners have decided to actually include plot and character development as equal priority. That has long been my only grouse about both Community and The Big Bang Theory. Both portrayed the main character (here the group and there Sheldon) as going through character developing arcs without changing at all at the end. Here Jeff and the group actually do develop from their egotistical exclusive personality and try to make Greendale a better place instead of just manipulating the system to suit them.

    The meta elements were also very well made. I especially liked that Jeff thought their history teacher (he actually was a teacher unlike 99% of Greendale’s staff) had singled them out to teach them a lesson as if they were ‘special’. This scene somewhat reminded me of Todd’s first episode where they blamed Todd for everything and it was all OK at the end. As if.

    Every person the group had mocked was there when they got their comeuppance from Leonard to Todd. I liked the references to previous episodes like the ‘bottle’ episode. It was as if the writers were making amends for making the show a little too fantastical and OTT.

    Also, Abed was given a character side plot that did not overstay its welcome.

    I’m a little divided on Chang’s amnesia arc, through Dean’s nurse outfit was the stuff of nightmares. But I prefer a bewildered Chang to the evil emperor Chang of last season.

    I agree with Jeff. Greendale has got better.

    Viewer score: 75 / 100

    Posted by Avishek, 02/03/2013 7:34am (4 years ago)

  • This was my favorite new Community episode yet. I was just a little bit irritated by the Hogan's Heroes/WWII analogies being a bit to explicit but I'll gladly take a little less subtly and a better more character movement. We might not get a Pillows and Blankets or a Remedial Chaos Theory but I'll gladly take a consistent Community that still makes me laugh.

    Chang has always been the show's biggest problem. Pierce and Chang are in a neck to neck race for unfunniest character. But if Chang is going to paired up with The Dean who is arguably the funniest character on the show I'm dean with that.

    Viewer score: 70 / 100

    Posted by Derek, 01/03/2013 9:59pm (4 years ago)

RSS feed for comments on this page | RSS feed for all comments